Pennsylvania

  • Facebook Social Icon

We hope you and others who visit this website find it useful.

If you would like to use material from the website, including our seminar slideshow, speakers' notes for the seminar, and/or videos of the seminar, please send a written request through the contact form on the index page of this website.

We grant licenses for use that is in keeping with our intent for CivicsForGrownups.org and the seminars it supports. The material on this website is protected by DMCA.

Unauthorized use of the materials is prohibited.

GERRYMANDERING

Gerrymandering is redistricting gone bad, a corruption of a process to keep equal numbers of voters in a state’s voting districts.

GERRYMANDERING - PURPOSE OF VOTING DISTRICTS

PA has three types of voting districts - each district directly elects one legislator

US House of Representatives - 18 districts - 18 Representatives

PA House of Representatives - 203 districts - 203 Representatives

PA Senate - 50 districts - 50 Senators

Districts influence the Electoral College and the Presidential election

 

GERRYMANDERING - WHY/HOW REDISTRICTING IS DONE

Population shifts over time. The US Census, done every 10 years tracks those changes.

After the Census, we redraw the boundaries of the districts so that they contain equal numbers of voters. Redistricting is supposed to create districts that do not divide towns, townships, school districts unless it is unavoidable.

 

PA’s Constitution establishes how redistricting is done:

a 5-person Commission

    US Congress recommends candidates

    PA State House & Senate appoint 4 members - 2 Republicans & 2 Democrats

    Those 4 people OR the PA Supreme Court picks 5th member

The people being elected (US House of Representatives and both State Houses) choose who draws the lines - therefore, the people being elected influence elections.

 

GERRYMANDERING - REDISTRICTING FOR POLITICAL ADVANTAGE

When a Commission draws lines to create a political advantage or disadvantage, the redistricting is Gerrymandering. This process got its name in 1812 - MA Governor Elbridge Gerry signed a district plan that favored Republicans; outraged Federalists gave the name “Gerrymandering” to the corrupt redistricting process.

 

GERRYMANDERING - WHY IS IT A PROBLEM

Protects favored incumbents

    moves lines to support them

    inhibits entry of new candidates

    limits our choices at the polls

Punishes incumbents who push back on the party

    moves lines to oust them

    encourages voting with the party    

    reduces importance of constituent priorities

Fosters partisan gridlock

The problem: politicians choose their voters - voters no longer choose their politicians.

 

GERRYMANDERING - IS IT A PROBLEM IN PA/HOW TO FIX IT

In 2010, the redistricting commission redrew lines that maintained equal populations in districts, but ignored the requirements to make districts compact and contiguous, and allowed lines to cut through towns, townships, school districts... Berks County has four districts. Their boundaries meander, bisect incorporated entities. Berks’ districts extend into SEVEN other counties.

 

In 2010, Project RedMap - a PAC, injected money into state elections, influenced who chose the redistricting commission, and helped to make our districts political tools. For 2020, we have both Project Redmap 2020 and Advantage 2020 waiting to do the same.

 

GERRYMANDERING - AMEND THE PA CONSTITUTION?

Senate Bill 22 and House Bill 722, if passed, would amend the Constitution

to create an 11-person Commission

    US Congress does not recommend candidates

    4 members from Democrats, 4 m

    members from Republicans    

    3 members from other parties

majority of 7 to pass a redistricting plan

 

The bills were introduced early in 2017.

To change redistricting process, they must be law before 2020.

By May, 86 legislators supported SB22.

    Some legislators like it as is.

    Some legislators believe the process is still to politicized.

    Some legislators believe that Gerrymandering is NOT a problem in PA.

A recent thrust is raising this issue to the US Supreme Court

 

What we need to do…

 

Look at the changes to the voting district boundaries.

Hold our state legislators accountable to have a fair redistricting approach.

Actively support legislators’ efforts to ensure fair redistricting.